Maybe the power of black lawyers is waning

Reading the National Association for Law Placement’s latest report on diversity in law firms like being hit by a yo-yo.

One minute of information will show you: In 2022, the cohort will be 49.4% women and 28.3% people of color – both highs – hooray!

The next minute, you’re hitting the floor: Among equal partners in Big Law, women and people of color are trailing far behind, comprising only 22.6% and 9%, respectively, this is the most desirable class.

If you forgot who was on top, the report explains it for you: “White men continue to be disproportionately represented among equal partners in multi-sector law firms .”

I didn’t intend to flip the script, but the NALP report suggested that women and people of color are making gains. The only question is whether those minor league wins will last.

High, Low for Black Lawyers

For Black lawyers, the yo-yo effect is even more pronounced. Unlike previous years, the Black partners seem to be having a break. NALP reported that the group was higher each year, representing 5.7% of all partners in 2022, compared to 5.2% the year before.

It’s also remarkable that they make up 11.8% of the latest summer partner crops, up almost 0.7% from last year.

But when it comes to partnerships, Black lawyers are still at a loss. Their rate increased by only 0.1% from last year, which is 2.3% of all partners, equal and unequal.

While the increase was also modest for Latinx partners (0.1% increase, representing 2.9% of all partners) and Asian partners (0.2% increase, representing 4.5% of all partners), it was there is hope that the Black partners will be higher.

Expectations were high because it has been more than two years since George Floyd was killed. Because of Big Law’s many promises to improve the DEI after that incident, you would expect better results in front of the Black partner other than a 0.1% reduction.

“The most frustrating part is the Black partner up front,” new NALP director Nikia Gray told me. “Their rate has gone up but it has increased significantly. At this rate, they won’t reach parity for another 30 years. That same plan is true for women, he added.

Some experts also fear that the jump in the Black associate rate is temporary and empty. “This increase happened during the 2021-2022 hiring process,” Yolanda Young, the founder of the Colored Lawyersremind me.

Noting the plight of lawyers during the Great Recession of 2008, he added, “If the past is any example, these gains will be quickly eroded by bankruptcy and the healing.”

The excitement is gone

That’s a really bad picture. Will Big Law abandon its young talent and commitment to diversity once the market winds change? It depends on whether you believe that Big Law’s embrace of social justice is an illusion or something deeper.

“I think people are really worried, although the intensity of the concern is not very high right now,” said Richard Banks, a professor at Stanford Law School and the founder of the Stanford Center for Racial Justice, to me.

“I know companies that really want to build an organization that includes everyone. … The bigger issue is that these problems are difficult, and good intentions fight against difficult realities. on business boards is easy, but integration in organizations is more difficult.

In fact, as NALP data shows, it is easier to fill minority positions with Black partners, but integration and promotion those in partnerships are more complex.

SCOTUS Fallout

But what is troubling is that we may not see these high numbers in small cases after the decision of the US Supreme Court in Harvard College and the University of North Carolina. admissions matter.

If the predictions are correct, the Supreme Court could end the case, or at least deal a major blow to an affirmative decision – which could be very serious. damaging the delicate pipe.

“It’s too early to tell what will happen, but we are very concerned about the issue,” said NALP’s Gray. “The impact is not just in terms of law school admissions; It can also affect diversity programs and other professional organizations.”

Although he said, “I haven’t seen much discussion about this issue on the part of the law firm – they are waiting and seeing the road.” But law schools are ready to act. “There’s detailed information going on about recruitment and what they can do legally.”

Stanford Banks, however, sees a silver lining in the prospect of eliminating collateral activity. “This can lead to more democratization of the work,” he said.

“Affirmative action has allowed us to operate under the illusion that we have to focus on higher education. It’s always about putting the best in the highest seats.” looking at the ranking system. Perhaps the results of the endorsement will cause employers to consider hiring from Howard instead of Stanford.

It is not in dispute that Black lawyers continue to face difficult challenges in the Big Law. “The data tells us that what we’ve been doing isn’t working,” Gray said. “The way companies are using it is wrong. It’s time for a serious review.”

‘Two Visions of Citizenship’

In the report and during our conversation, Gray criticized the organization of law firms, especially the use of discussions about DEI almost exclusively for lawyers, creating what he called “two classes the citizen-lawyers and all other people” and “in the people and outside the people.”

To make progress, he added, “companies need to re-examine the whole organization and look at it more closely.”

That may be true, but it surprised me like pie-in-the-sky. Law firms tend to stress the relationship between lawyers and non-lawyers as they eat away at the billable hour.

So I encouraged Gray about the glimmer of hope that diversity will continue to be a priority in the current system.

His answer: “Companies are facing a lot of pressure from customers for diversity, and that pressure has increased after the murder of George Floyd and the national conversation about race.”

As for companies that are not perfect, Gray said he has noticed that “companies are starting to pull jobs.” But even independent of this pressure, he added, “although companies are businesses, they are made up of individuals who want to do the right thing.”

There may be a desire to “do the right thing” but, as any child knows, that is not enough.

Leave a Comment