Is a short term mortgage still worth it?

Regardless of the intent, the market rewards borrowers for risk. Over five years, the risk-reward ratio of taking back a one-year fixed mortgage remains favorable.Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press

Mortgage brokers are increasing the Bank of Canada prices will be cut within a year. That is the best guide to avoid being locked in for a long time.

The problem is, short-term rates are higher compared to longer-term ones mortgage Borrowers are trying to avoid it. The nation’s lowest annual uninsured rate was 5.74 percent, for example, compared to 5.09 percent for the five-year average.

The one-year high reflects investors’ expectation that the Bank of Canada (BoC) will keep interest rates high for three to four more quarters, before lowering rates. said Royce Mendes, Desjardins managing director and head of macro strategy.

The policy rate is 4.25 percent can jump to less than 4.5 percent at the BoC meeting next week, it is “not sustainable for a long time,” he said.

But here it gets interesting.

fixed mortgage rates that track government bond yields over time. “The five-year rate is a reflection of the average BoC rate expected over five years,” said Mr. Mendes, with a small investment to pay investors for making long-term capital.

McLister: This week’s lowest fixed and variable mortgages in Canada

How home financing affects new mortgage applications

Similarly, the one-year rate reflects the BoC’s expected rate over the next 12 months.

If you believe, however, that the markets are the best predictor of future rates – and although they are always wrong, it is really the best they have, said Mr. Mendes – this means “there is absolutely no way to negotiate the way for interests.”

In other words, “It will be difficult for families to have a model against market prices if they only see the future,” he said.

Okay, so if rates are really good, does it matter what mortgage term people choose?

“That’s why we face problems – that education doesn’t reflect the truth,” said Mr. Mendes.

Research published by the University of York Moshe Milevsky found that choosing a variable mortgage is about four out of five historical times, he said. One-year mortgages have the same edge.

But floating or going short-term can offer a lower level today than 20 years ago, because there is more room then for falling prices, the article which Mr. Mendes.

However, the plan is not fully effective, he said. There is still room for rates to fall as they appear to be close to cycle highs and given that they should land around 2 per cent above the Bank of Canada for the long term “neutral rate.”

The neutral rate is the rate of policy that does not stimulate or slow the economy and keeps inflation at 2 percent. The BoC thinks it lies between 2 and 3 percent.

Do past research rates still apply?

“I haven’t seen anything that really changes the ratio since the study, and the consistency of that variable rate it’s better because you’re not paying for a guaranteed rate,” said Mr. Milevsky. In fact, you are being paid based on the risk level of the lender.

Yes, five-year fixed-term mortgages have the lowest rates right now, but that’s mostly because the Bank of Canada has cut interest rates and is now buying five-year mortgages. year. Barring another sudden rate hike, variable and short-term rates will eventually fall below five-year fixed rates, six of which into next year.

Regardless of the intent, the market rewards borrowers for risk. Over five years, the risk-reward ratio of taking back a one-year fixed mortgage remains favorable. The fact that today is one year too high doesn’t change that.

Mr. has warned Milevsky borrowers to think about more than just difficulties, however.

For example, there is enough chance that the price of houses may decrease next year, he said. If so, it could prevent some borrowers from having enough equity to qualify for a new loan. On the other hand, they can be stuck with high renewal rates from their existing loans.

On the other hand, someone who buys an expensive, high-use home with a down payment would be wiser to lock in at least a portion of their loan, he said.

But what mortgage will Mr. Milevksy now, if you ask him he will note that everyone has a different balance.

“I’m floating,” he said. “I don’t lock in time, because I can handle the risk. On average, I think I will pay less and I can focus on averages. Many people can’t.”

This week’s price

Low mortgage rates in the country



Period The insurance Deliver Insurance Deliver
1-year tenure 5.74% Ratehub 4.64% QuestMortgage
2-year tenure 5.64% Ratehub 4.64% QuestMortgage
3-year tenure 5.24% Ratehub 4.59% QuestMortgage
4-year tenure 5.19% Ratehub 4.64% QuestMortgage
5-year tenure 5.09% HSBC 4.54% Ratehub
10-year tenure 5.94% HSBC 5.54% Something
Exchange 5.90% Ratehub 5.25% Something
5-year hybrid 5.57% HSBC 5.94% Scotia eHOME
HELOC * 6.45% HSBC n/a n/a

Source: Robert McLister; data as of January 19

Rates are as of January 19, 2023 from companies that publish online rates and credit in at least nine counties. The insurance rates apply to those who are buying with less than 20 percent down, or those who are changing a previous mortgage to a new loan. Uninsured rates apply to refinances and purchases over $1-million and may include premiums owed. For companies whose prices vary by province, their highest value is shown.


Robert McLister is an interest rate analyst, mortgage broker and director of MortgageLogic.news. You can follow him on Twitter at @RobMcLister.

Leave a Comment